SAN JOSE, CA − Should the Seattle Seahawks have simply run the ball?
It’s a question that’s been posed countless times over the past decade-plus but has returned to the forefront with a vengeance this week as Seattle prepares to play the New England Patriots in Super Bowl 60 − 11 years after the Seahawks’ stunning, controversial, pall-casting 28-24 loss to the Pats in their last Super Sunday appearance.
‘I know that’s a sore subject for a lot of people but, uh … we’ll say pass?’ current Seahawks QB Sam Darnold smiled when asked the question during Super Bowl Opening Night on Feb. 2. (Wrong answer, Sam.)
Said Seattle receiver Cooper Kupp: ‘I would say probably hand the ball off.’ (Bingo.)
Head coach Mike Macdonald had had about enough after fielding the same query from multiple media members Monday.
‘I think the more important question is how many times am I gonna get this question over the next three days?’ is where a slightly exasperated Macdonald landed.
It’s a fairly understandable response given the typical Groundhog Day patina of Super Bowl coverage. And that’s especially true given neither Macdonald, Darnold, Kupp nor anyone on the present roster was part of the Seattle team that so memorably failed in Super Bowl 49, a defeat that potentially precluded a Seahawks dynasty while breathing new life into the Bill Belichick and Tom Brady-era Patriots − who had not won a Super Bowl in 10 years prior to that magnificent escape act. (They would go on to capture two additional Lombardi Trophies over the following four years, bringing their total to six, tied with the Pittsburgh Steelers for most won by a single NFL franchise.)
The laundry may be the same, but this weekend’s game hardly qualifies as a rematch. Yet Macdonald was asked again − sort of − on Feb. 4, the question repackaged in a way to suggest the 2025 Seahawks might be motivated to avenge the 2014 edition.
After a brief pause, Macdonald responded (with a laugh), ‘No. We haven’t talked about it once.’
If you’re even a semi-casual football fan, then you probably remember the particulars of the play in question. If not? Then consider this a learning experience as it kicks off my list of the 60 most memorable plays on Super Sunday going into Super Bowl 60:
1. Malcolm Butler’s INT
Pivotal. Shocking. Unforgettable. The Patriots’ undrafted rookie cornerback made the rarest of plays, snatching victory from the jaws of defeat by intercepting Seahawks QB Russell Wilson at the goal line with 20 seconds left to preserve the four-point win in Super Bowl 49.
‘I can’t believe the (play) call,’ NBC analyst Cris Collinsworth, who will also call Super Bowl 60, said at the time. ‘You have Marshawn Lynch. You have a guy who’s been borderline unstoppable. … If I lose this Super Bowl because Marshawn Lynch can’t get into the end zone, so be it. So be it. I can’t believe the call.’
In the process, Butler derailed Seattle’s title defense a year after they’d won Super Bowl 48 in dominant fashion over Peyton Manning’s Denver Broncos and launched a lifetime of second guessing for the legions who skewered coach Pete Carroll for not directing Wilson to hand off to Lynch, one of the most formidable backs in league history and a guy who’d already scored a touchdown and racked up 133 total yards in that game. Last, yet certainly not least, Butler saved Brady and coach Belichick from the narrative that they were ‘only’ 3-3 in Super Bowls to that point. Way to just “do your job,’ Malcolm Butler!
“It probably runs across my mind at least once a week,” Butler told USA TODAY Sports’ Jarrett Bell earlier this week. “I sit around the house, and I’m so grateful for all the things I’ve got. Even if I didn’t make that play, my life was going to be good, because I was always a hustler, a grinder, who is going to make things happen, no matter what. But that really changed my life.’
2. Roethlisberger-to-Holmes
What was better, QB Ben Roethlisberger’s precision strike to the back corner of the end zone – rifled through three Arizona Cardinals – or WR Santonio Holmes’ ability to snatch it while keeping his toes down as he fell out of bounds with 35 seconds on the clock? Beautifully executed all the way around, and it gave the Pittsburgh Steelers a then-record sixth Lombardi Trophy as they rallied for a 27-23 victory in Super Bowl 43.
3. David Tyree’s helmet catch
Most coaches would cringe if their quarterback threw into triple coverage in the middle of the field while scrambling amid a broken play. But that’s what New York Giants star Eli Manning did, and Tyree famously managed to pin the pass against his helmet on the other end of the 32-yard hookup with 59 seconds to go. Four plays later, Manning hit WR Plaxico Burress for the game-winning TD as the Giants shocked the previously undefeated Patriots in Super Bowl 42.
4. Montana-to-Taylor
The San Francisco 49ers’ game-winning march began with QB Joe Montana surveying the stands and asking teammates in the huddle, ‘Isn’t that John Candy?’ Joe Cool indeed. Eleven plays and 92 yards later, WR John Taylor caught the decisive 10-yard pass from Montana with 34 seconds to go as the Niners overcame the Cincinnati Bengals 20-16 in Super Bowl 23.
5. Wide right
That’s where Buffalo Bills kicker Scott Norwood’s 47-yard field-goal try (barely) missed with 4 seconds left in Super Bowl 25. The Giants hung on for a 20-19 win, and Buffalo would never get any closer to a title despite reaching Super Sunday three more times.
6. Mike Jones’ tackle
With the Tennessee Titans 10 yards away from a potential game-tying touchdown with 5 seconds to play in Super Bowl 34, Jones, an unheralded St. Louis Rams linebacker, limited WR Kevin Dyson to a 9-yard gain – just shy of the goal line – on the game-ending play.
7. Adam Vinatieri’s Super Bowl 36 field goal
On the final snap, the Patriots kicker split the uprights from 48 yards – he was celebrating before the ball went through – literally kick-starting the New England dynasty and completing one of the Super Bowl’s biggest upsets as the Pats knocked off the heavily favored ‘Greatest Show on Turf’ Rams 20-17. Vinatieri would drill an only slightly less dramatic FG in the final seconds two years later to beat the Carolina Panthers.
8. ’70 chip’
That was the play call by Washington, which trailed the Miami Dolphins 17-13, on fourth-and-1 in the fourth quarter of Super Bowl 17. The ball went to RB John Riggins, who, running behind his dominant ‘Hogs’ offensive line, ran through the tackle of DB Don McNeal before busting down the left sideline for a 43-yard touchdown the Fins wouldn’t overcome.
9. Tracy Porter’s pick-six
With QB Peyton Manning and the Indianapolis Colts 31 yards from a game-tying touchdown with less than four minutes to go in Super Bowl 44, the New Orleans Saints corner swiped a pass intended for WR Reggie Wayne and set sail for a game-icing 74-yard TD.
10. James White in OT
The largely anonymous third-down back of the Patriots ran 2 yards to glory in the first Super Sunday overtime, capping New England’s epic comeback from a 28-3 deficit against the Atlanta Falcons in Super Bowl 51 while boosting his Super Bowl single-game record point total to 20.
11. Mecole Hardman in OT
The largely anonymous receiver of the Kansas City Chiefs caught the game-winning 3-yard TD pass from QB Patrick Mahomes − on a play called ‘Corn Dog’ − in the second Super Sunday overtime, K.C. securing back-to-back championships with its Super Bowl 58 triumph in Las Vegas.
12. We’re No. 1
Joe Namath’s raised index finger as he jogged off the Orange Bowl field after the New York Jets’ monumental upset of the Baltimore Colts in Super Bowl 3 said it all, especially after the MVP’s famous pregame guarantee that the 18-point underdogs would prevail.
13. Doug Williams’ comeback
The Washington quarterback crumbled to the turf while being sacked in the first quarter, his surgically repaired left knee hyperextended with his team trailing the Denver Broncos 10-0. But Williams would miss just two plays before launching four TD passes in the next period on his way to becoming MVP and the first Black quarterback to win a Super Bowl as Washington cruised to a 42-10 rout in Super Bowl 22.
14. James Harrison’s INT return
The Steelers pass-rushing linebacker dropped into coverage on a hunch and picked off Cardinals QB Kurt Warner at the goal line before a 100-yard tightrope sprint up the sideline for a TD completed what was at least a 10-point swing before halftime in Super Bowl 43, which Pittsburgh won by four points.
15. Terry Bradshaw KO’d
As he launched what would prove to be the decisive 64-yard TD pass to WR Lynn Swann in the fourth quarter of Super Bowl 10, the chin of the Steelers quarterback was introduced to the helmet of Dallas Cowboys DL Larry Cole. Bradshaw was out before he hit the ground and wouldn’t play again in the game, but his throw earned Pittsburgh its second ring.
16. Isaac Bruce’s TD
It gets overshadowed by Jones’ tackle, but the Rams don’t win without Warner’s 73-yard TD pass to Bruce with 1:54 to go on St. Louis’ first play after the Titans had erased a 16-0 deficit.
17. Burrow bagged
Trailing 23-20 inside the final minute of Super Bowl 56, Bengals QB Joe Burrow was trying to pull one more rabbit out of the hat from midfield. Instead, Los Angeles Rams DL Aaron Donald burst through the line on what turned out to be Cincy’s final play, ragdolling Joey B. into a desperation incompletion that put the game on ice – Donald pointing to his ring finger, indicating where his new ice would be featured.
18. Favre-to-Rison
Vintage Brett Favre. On the Green Bay Packers’ second play of Super Bowl 31, the MVP quarterback called an audible before launching a 54-yard touchdown to WR Andre Rison streaking down the middle of the field. Favre sprinted after his receiver, helmet held aloft, and Green Bay was on its way to its first title in 29 years.
19. John Elway’s helicopter run
The 37-year-old Broncos quarterback, in desperate pursuit of his first title after being blown out in his first three Super Sunday starts, famously went airborne and was spun around by Packers defenders on an 8-yard third-quarter run that gave Denver a first-and-goal. It set up MVP Terrell Davis’ go-ahead TD run in Super Bowl 32, which the Broncos eventually won 31-24.
20. Mario Manningham’s catch
Four years after being victimized by Tyree, the Patriots fell prey to an amazing 38-yard completion from Eli Manning to Manningham with 3:39 to go on the Giants’ game-winning drive of Super Bowl 46. Manningham barely got his feet down at midfield, a play the Patriots unsuccessfully challenged.
21. Jackie Smith’s drop
The Hall of Fame tight end, wide open in the end zone, dropped a perfect pass from Cowboys QB Roger Staubach in Super Bowl 13 that would have knotted the game 21-21, prompting broadcaster Verne Lundquist to exclaim, ‘Bless his heart, he’s got to be the sickest man in America.’ Yep. The Cowboys would eventually lose to the Steelers 35-31.
22. 2-3 Jet Chip Wasp
Trailing by 10 with more than half the fourth quarter expired and facing a third-and-15 from his own 35-yard line in Super Bowl 54, Mahomes knew his team was backed into a corner. But he suggested this play, which required WR Tyreek Hill to run a late-developing route deep into San Francisco’s zone coverage. Mahomes took the snap and had to drop 14 yards into the pocket in order to evade the 49ers’ relentless pass rush, then heaved the ball toward Hill, who’d cut toward the sideline to find a soft spot in the zone. The result was a 44-yard completion that set up a Mahomes TD pass three plays later and opened the floodgates for K.C.’s belated 21-point outburst and first championship in 50 years.
23. Julian Edelman’s shoestring snatch
The Patriots’ slot man extraordinaire snared a ball that was deflected (and nearly intercepted) by Falcons CB Robert Alford microns above the turf, extending New England’s game-tying drive after the team had fallen behind by 25 points in the second half of Super Bowl 51. It was also a welcome turn of events to Pats fans, who’d suffered through script-flipping catches by Tyree and Manningham.
24. Jim O’Brien’s kick
The Baltimore Colts rookie saw his first extra-point try blocked and missed his initial field-goal attempt in a mistake-laden Super Bowl 5. But his 32-yard FG with 5 seconds left gave the Colts a 16-13 defeat of the Cowboys in the Super Bowl’s first truly dramatic moment.
25. ‘Philly Special’
It’s already earned its spot in Super Bowl lore as the enduring moment of the Philadelphia Eagles’ long-awaited Super Bowl 52 victory. However, QB Nick Foles’ 1-yard TD grab from TE Trey Burton off a reverse, on fourth-and-goal just before halftime, was really more gutsy than conclusive given the Patriots eventually overcame (temporarily) the 22-12 hole they fell into on the play.
26. The lights go out in New Orleans
With the 49ers trailing the Baltimore Ravens 28-6 in the third quarter of Super Bowl 47, half of the Superdome’s lights lost power, causing a 34-minute delay. The Niners surged back, eventually cutting the lead to two, before ultimately succumbing.
27. 49ers’ goal-line stand
Up 20-7 in the third quarter of Super Bowl 16, San Francisco turned the Bengals away three times from the 1-yard line, including LB Dan Bunz’s open-field tackle of Charles Alexander on a third-down swing pass. The 49ers would hang on 26-21 for their first title.
28. Ty Law’s pick-six
Decided underdogs against the Rams in 2002, the Patriots were hanging around in the second quarter, trailing 3-0. But Law pilfered a Warner pass down the right sideline intended for Bruce and, arm held high, raced 47 yards for a touchdown and 7-3 lead New England wouldn’t relinquish.
29. John Kasay’s errant kickoff
The Panthers had just tied Super Bowl 38 at 29-29 with 73 seconds to go. Then Kasay booted the ensuing kickoff out of bounds, putting Brady and the Patriots at their own 40-yard line. Six plays and 37 yards was all they needed to set up Vinatieri for the game winner.
30. Seahawks safety
On the first play from scrimmage in Super Bowl 48, Broncos C Manny Ramirez’s snap sailed over the head of Peyton Manning and into the end zone, giving Seattle a 2-0 lead. No one knew it then, but the game was essentially over as the Seahawks would score the first 36 points in a 43-8 laugher.
31. Garo’s gaffe
The Dolphins’ Cyprus-born kicker made the team’s bid for a 17-0 season too close for comfort in Super Bowl 7. Trying to give Miami a serendipitous 17-0 lead with less than three minutes to go, Yepremian’s 42-yard field-goal attempt was blocked. He unwisely tried to pass the ball after collecting the rebound, and it ended up in the hands of Mike Bass, who took it 49 yards for Washington’s only score.
32. Graham cracker
The play didn’t garner the cachet of the ‘Philly Special,’ but Eagles DE Brandon Graham’s strip sack of Brady with 2:09 remaining in Super Bowl 52 was the key (only?) defensive play on a day when the teams combined for an NFL record 1,151 yards of offense. Brady’s fumble occurred with New England trailing 38-33 and led to Philly’s game-icing field goal.
33. Ahmad Bradshaw’s TD mistake
The Giants tailback scored what proved to be a game-winning 6-yard TD with 57 seconds left in Super Bowl 46, which New York would win 21-17. However the Patriots let Bradshaw into the end zone in order to get the ball back to Brady – New York could have milked the clock before a chip-shot field goal – which he realized too late as he awkwardly fell into the paint. (The Packers used a similar tactic 14 years before, also unsuccessfully.) Ultimately, no harm, no foul for Bradshaw.
34. John Stallworth’s big catch
He’s often overshadowed by teammate Swann, but Stallworth’s 73-yard TD grab from Bradshaw in the fourth quarter finally put the Steelers ahead for good in what had been a nip-and-tuck Super Bowl 14 against the L.A. Rams.
35. Marcus Allen’s 74-yard TD
It was really icing on the cake as the Los Angeles Raiders took a 35-9 third-quarter lead over Washington in Super Bowl 18. But the MVP’s ability to find daylight after reversing his field on what looked like a doomed play had President Ronald Reagan quipping after the game: ‘I have already got a call from Moscow. They think Marcus Allen is a new secret weapon and they insist that we dismantle him.’
36. U2’s halftime show
It’s not universally regarded as the greatest intermission performance on Super Sunday … but it should be. Bono, Edge, Larry Mullen and Adam Clayton concluded their three-song set with ‘Where the Streets Have No Name’ as the names of those killed on Sept. 11 just a few months prior scrolled on a scrim suspended from the Superdome’s roof. The 2001 terrorist attacks forced the NFL season to be temporarily suspended and ultimately moved Super Bowl 36 back a week, marking the first time the game was played in February.
37. Ambush
The play call of the Saints’ surprise onside kick by Thomas Morstead to start the second half of Super Bowl 44. New Orleans recovered and soon scored a go-ahead TD.
38. Vince Lombardi carried off
The iconic Packers coach, reviled by many of his players a decade earlier but eventually beloved, rode off the field on the shoulders of his charges, including G Jerry Kramer, as Green Bay won its fifth and final title of the 1960s by winning Super Bowl 2. It was Lombardi’s final game as the team’s coach.
39. Buddy Ryan carried off
The defensive coordinator of the famed 1985 Chicago Bears defense got the same treatment as head coach Mike Ditka after a 46-10 blowout of the Patriots in Super Bowl 20. It was emblematic of divided loyalties on a team that wouldn’t win another title after Ryan left to coach the Eagles.
40. Jerome Bettis leaves tunnel alone
The Hall of Fame running back was playing his final game in his hometown, Detroit, for Super Bowl 40. Bettis charged out of the tunnel for pregame introductions and, unbeknownst to him, LB Joey Porter held the rest of the Steelers back to give his teammate a special moment. Eventually realizing he was isolated on the field, a beaming Bettis beckoned his teammates to join him in a game they would win 21-10.
41. Super Bowl’s first TD
It was scored by Packers WR Max McGee, who was only playing because of an injury to teammate Boyd Dowler. McGee was less than 100% after a long night of partying, but you’d never know as he reached behind his back for an underthrown pass from QB Bart Starr on a 37-yard score that got Green Bay on course for a 35-10 win over the Chiefs.
42. Jacoby Jones’ heroics
Few had heard of him before he ended the Ravens’ final drive in the first half of Super Bowl 47 with a 56-yard TD catch. Jones then opened the second half with a record 108-yard kickoff return for a TD that gave Baltimore a 28-6 lead that proved too much for the 49ers … even with help from that power outage.
43. Whoops, Leon Lett
The mishaps of the Cowboys defensive tackle have overshadowed an otherwise sterling career. But we can’t forget that his showboating on a 64-yard fumble return in Super Bowl 27 enabled Bills WR Don Beebe to swat the ball out of Lett’s paw for a touchback just short of another Dallas touchdown. It prevented the triumphant Cowboys from scoring a game record 59 points.
44. 65 Toss Power Trap
Chiefs coach Hank Stram, famously mic’d up as NFL Films tried what was a new technique at the time, gleefully called the play that would result in a 5-yard Mike Garrett touchdown and a 16-0 lead in Super Bowl 4, which Kansas City would go on to win 23-7 against the heavily favored Minnesota Vikings.
45. Peace
46. Jack Lambert sticks up for teammate
Steelers K Roy Gerela had a rough Super Bowl 10, missing two field goals and an extra point. But when Cowboys S Cliff Harris patted Gerela on the helmet after his 33-yard misfire in the third quarter, Lambert – Pittsburgh’s menacing middle linebacker – flung Harris to the turf and stood over him. Dallas players later admitted Harris’ taunt infuriated the Steelers, who trailed 10-7 at the time but outscored Dallas 14-7 in the fourth quarter to prevail.
47. Wardrobe Malfunction
Admit it, Janet Jackson’s halftime ‘slip’ provided your most vivid memory of Super Bowl 38.
48. ‘Somebody take the monkey off my back!’
After throwing a Super Bowl record six TD passes (and finally escaping Montana’s considerable shadow), MVP Steve Young couldn’t contain his relief with this statement near the end of the 49ers’ 49-26 blowout of the San Diego Chargers in Super Bowl 29.
49. Jermaine Kearse’s catch
His miraculous, tumbling, 33-yard grab at the Patriots’ 10-yard line with 76 seconds to go seemed destined for a spot alongside Tyree and Manningham as surreal completions that would vanquish New England yet again. (Ironically enough, it was Butler whom Kearse beat in coverage.) Sadly for Seattle, Wilson’s next pass wasn’t nearly as effective.
50. John Mackey’s TD
The tight end got the Baltimore Colts back into Super Bowl 5 with a game-tying 75-yard TD from fellow Hall of Famer Johnny Unitas in the second quarter. The catch was memorable because it deflected off the fingertips of Colts WR Ed Hinton and Dallas CB Mel Renfro before settling into Mackey’s hands. The play would have been illegal at the time if Renfro had not touched it – and the Cowboys vehemently argued he didn’t in a game they would lose by three points.
51. Lynn Swann’s juggling catch
The 53-yard reception over Dallas’ Mark Washington was the prettiest of Swann’s four receptions in Super Bowl 10, when he earned MVP honors. However, as aesthetically pleasing as it was, the catch didn’t lead to any Pittsburgh points.
52. Gatorade shower
Still a novel celebration in 1987, it was first seen on Super Sunday when Giants LB Harry Carson, disguised in a security guard’s jacket, dumped the drink on coach Bill Parcells at the end of New York’s 39-20 Super Bowl 21 win.
53. Fridge scores
The ’85 Bears’ coronation in Super Bowl 20 was never in doubt, and DT William ‘The Refrigerator’ Perry’s 1-yard TD run for a 44-3 lead in the third quarter may have been the crowning moment. Sadly, Ditka belatedly realized it came at the cost of providing legendary RB Walter Payton the Super Bowl score he had long dreamed of but wouldn’t realize.
54. Desmond Howard’s TD
His 99-yard kickoff return provided the final score in Green Bay’s 35-21 win in Super Bowl 31 and made him the only special teamer to win MVP honors.
55. Run, Willie, run
On the second play after halftime in Super Bowl 40, Steelers RB ‘Fast Willie’ Parker broke a 75-yard TD run, the longest in Super Bowl history, that would give Pittsburgh an insurmountable 14-3 lead over Seattle.
56. Devin Hester’s kickoff return
Few thought the Indianapolis Colts would kick to the Bears special teams ace, who had six TD returns in the 2006 regular season. But Hester took Vinatieri’s game-opening kickoff 92 yards to the house with the kicker flailing to stop him at the end of it. Unfortunately for Hester, he didn’t get another opportunity in a game Chicago lost 29-17.
57. Larry Fitzgerald’s almost day
It seemed the Cardinals star had capped an unforgettable postseason – he had 30 catches for 546 yards and seven TDs in four games – in style when his 64-yard catch-and-run TD with 2:37 to go in Super Bowl 43 gave Arizona its first lead. Unfortunately for Fitzgerald, he left Roethlisberger and Holmes too much time.
58. OBJ’s emotional day
Making his Super Sunday debut in Super Bowl 56, Rams WR Odell Beckham Jr. opened the scoring against Cincinnati with a 17-yard TD catch from Matthew Stafford in the first quarter. But Beckham wound up celebrating LA’s victory in street clothes after suffering a torn ACL before halftime.
59. T.O.’s big day
Seven weeks after breaking his leg, Eagles WR Terrell Owens caught nine passes for 122 yards in Super Bowl 39. His courageous effort wasn’t quite enough in a three-point loss to the Patriots, but Jack Youngblood − Owens’ fellow Hall of Famer played on a broken leg himself in the Rams’ Super Bowl 14 loss − was still proud.
60. Hightower’s heroics
Let’s end back at the beginning. Former Patriots LB Dont’a Hightower is probably best known for his momentum-fueling strip sack of Falcons QB Matt Ryan during New England’s Super Bowl 51 comeback. But Hightower’s biggest Super Sunday moment occurred two years earlier. Before Butler’s mythic pick, Hightower, soldiering with a torn labrum in his shoulder, somehow brought down Lynch for a 4-yard gain on the previous play. Had it been a 5-yard gain, Seattle almost certainly wins Super Bowl 49 and NFL history looks much different.